Much like my barely legible high school handwriting has degraded across a quarter-century of typing on computers, my natural urge to stop and save a game faded away. I blame the emergence of automatic saving, checkpoints, console quick-resume features, and experiences where the risk feels so great that I instinctively save constantly just in case disaster strikes. Yet, I am fallible. Laziness creeps in. And this week, I learned a crucial piece of wisdom deep into a session of the fresh Switch version of Pokémon FireRed for Nintendo Switch: you must still smash that save button.
It had been years since I engaged with one of the 2D Pokémon games — never experiencing the Game Boy Advance, the Johto region games may have been the final core Pokémon game I played. Consequently, I was thrilled to pony up the asking price for a trip down memory lane to the land of the original 151, and a run to catch those classic 151 creatures. I immediately snapped back to a simpler time. Across several nights, I was catching bugs, picked up an early Pikachu, beat Brock without trouble, took a chance on purchasing the future Gyarados from the salesman in the Pokémon Center, and traversed Mt. Moon carefree and confident.
The critical error: I failed to save even once! The idea simply didn't occur to me.
That Jigglypuff shall never be friends with that Mankey.
The catastrophe occurred during a session when I wasn't even playing… and as my daughter grabbed the Switch for a quick half-hour of Pokémon Z-A instead, shutting down my session to do so. As we all know (a fact I foolishly ignored…) launching a different title on Switch will close your current game. Your data is only preserved when an autosave triggers or you saved manually before switching. Whoops.
The Development of Game Saves: From Manual to Automatic
One could view autosave, now so effortless its operation is largely unconscious, as a true “next-gen” breakthrough. Whereas the early computer game Zork had one of the earliest save functions in a game, the original NES Legend of Zelda is widely hailed as a pivotal point for not feeling utterly defeated following a character's death thanks to persistent memory saves on the classic console. Naturally, the responsibility remained to save. (And after one flub), the lesson was learned for life. Through the 1990s, external memory cards including the original PlayStation normalized the save process yet still fragile; forgetting to save (or having a card corrupt) could erase countless hours. The survival horror series Resident Evil took it further by transforming saving into a limited resource.
Modern autosave, that eroded my instinct to save my retro gaming session so completely, became standard at the dawn of a new century. The first Halo had its automatic checkpoints while Call of Duty honed the approach to smooth difficulty and remove unnecessary grinding. As the play grew longer — and focused on exploration — programmers mastered the technique on constant background saves and, eventually, the ultimate convenience of instant on/off.
The Pokémon Series' Path: From Conscious Choice to Unconscious Backup
Curiously, this iconic franchise is a great reflection of that historical progression. For a long time, saving in a Pokémon game was a deliberate choice: players were trained to manually record their data ahead of powering down their handheld console. Starting with Pokémon Sword and Shield for the Nintendo Switch, the series introduced an autosave feature (at first as a toggleable option), marking a major design shift for a franchise known as staunchest upholders of tradition.
I own up to my blunder: Countless hours spent in Breath of the Wild and recent platformers totally eroded my instinct to save. I am still wary under specific circumstances — I won’t even gamble bailing mid-run in something like Hades 2 even knowing it saves progress automatically — however, perhaps due to the lengthy gap since I last invested older game design, or I'm simply pampered, it didn’t even occur to me to preserve my progress before redocking. Seven-year-old me would not have made such a mistake to this degree.
The Consequences: A Burned-Out Trainer
I have not picked up FireRed following the great progress wipe. When I saw the title screen again and discovered my team consisted solely of the beginning Squirtle, my motivation evaporated. My personal status: Burned.
Maybe I’ll go back… or perhaps I'll remain in the hundreds of new games available now that operate under the assumption I need my hand held. Still, my affection for classic games persists. When I can pry my daughter away from the modern, auto-saving Pokémon game, we have been cooperatively playing Switch 2’s Super Bomberman Collection. Those early SNES games skipped saving altogether opting instead for cryptic character strings. Thus, when I meet an explosive end, it’s not a total loss. That, at least, is reassuring.